Some homes try to be impressive. This one just naturally is.
Tucked behind the private gates of Tidy Island, 41 Tidy Island Blvd is one of the island’s rare freestanding homes and is being offered for the first time by its original owner. The house has the kind of presence that feels straight out of a coastal Southern story. Tall ceilings, generous windows, and the kind of setting that makes guests linger on the porch a little longer than planned. The backdrop is Sarasota Bay. Dolphins pass through from time to time. Egrets patrol the shoreline like they’re on official business. And sunsets tend to make even the most talkative guests go quiet for a minute.
Homes like this rarely come along in the area, where many newer houses tend to follow the same builder-grade formula. This one has something different. Real character, thoughtful design, and the kind of details that make a home feel substantial the moment you walk in. Step through the doors into a grand two-story foyer that immediately sets the tone. Inside, you’ll find wood floors, a wood-burning fireplace, and a kitchen equipped with a Sub-Zero refrigerator that anchors the heart of the home. The layout feels both welcoming and refined, designed for gathering while still offering quiet spaces to retreat.
Tidy Island has always done things a little differently. When the community was developed in the 1980s, the plan was simple. Build thoughtfully and leave the rest alone. About 85 percent of the island’s 240 acres was preserved as wildlife habitat, which means mangroves, shorebirds, and the occasional manatee still outnumber golf carts of tourists. Walking trails wind through the preserve, and most days the loudest sound you hear is the wind through the palms. Despite the peaceful setting, you are only minutes from town. IMG Academy, Bradenton Christian School, St. Stephens, SRQ airport, and the beaches are all nearby. The new Seaflower Village district is also beginning to bring a fresh mix of dining and shopping to the area.
41 Tidy Island Blvd is offered for sale by me, representing the original owner. If you stop by for a tour, there’s a good chance I’ll be there practicing a few of my favorite lines from Gone With the Wind.Listed at $1,995,000, this distinctive waterfront residence offers over 4,000 square feet of living space, timeless architecture, and one of the most unique settings in the area.
